• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Dallas Immigration Lawyer VERDIN LAW • Immigration Attorney

Dallas Immigration Lawyer VERDIN LAW • Immigration Attorney

  • About
    • About VERDIN
    • FAQs
    • Isaul Verdin, Esq.
  • Practice Areas
    • Business Based Immigration
      • Non-Immigrant
      • Permanent Residency
      • E1 and E2 Visas
    • Family Based Immigration
      • Non-Permanent Residency
      • Permanent Residency
      • Deferred Action, Crime Victims, and Other Humanitarian Relief
      • Naturalization and Citizenship
    • Deportation Defense
  • Reviews
  • News
    • News and Info
    • VERDIN Videos
  • Contact

VERDIN Law - Dallas Immigration Attorney

Fifth Circuit Vacates Silva-Trevino

You are here: Home / VERDIN Blogs / Fifth Circuit Vacates Silva-Trevino
December 22, 2015

lady-justice-278x300Immigrant rights advocates have reason to celebrate!  In a move long hoped for by immigration attorneys in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit joined four other circuit courts in holding that immigration judges and the Board of Immigration Appeals may not look beyond the record of an alien’s conviction to determine whether that conviction constitutes a crime involving moral turpitude (CIMT).

The January 31, 2014 panel decision brings a sigh of relief to immigration rights advocates after years of legal wrangling.  Functionally, what the decision means is that immigration adjudicators will be limited to examining only the statute of conviction (an analysis known as the “categorical inquiry”) and, if necessary, a limited set of court documents constituting the alien’s “record of conviction,” (the “modified categorical inquiry”) to determine the nature of an alien respondent’s offense.  The decision ensures that the determination of whether an alien’s conviction constitutes a CIMT can only be made based on conduct for which the alien was actually convicted.  The ruling excludes from consideration things like police reports, witness affidavits, oral testimony, and other documents which may contain allegations of unsavory conduct for which the alien was never convicted.

The Fifth’s ruling strikes down what has come to be known as the Silva-Trevino “third step.”  For at least a century courts have used what is known as the “categorical inquiry” to determine whether an alien has been “convicted of” a particular type of offense, such as a CIMT.  However, in 2008, then Attorney General of the United States Alberto Gonzales certified to himself the Board of Immigration Appeals’ decision in Matter of Silva-Trevino, which had determined under the categorical analysis that the respondent’s offense was not a CIMT.  In an unprecedented expansion of executive authority, the Attorney General overruled the Board’s earlier decision and determined that immigration judges and the Board were authorized, when necessary, to look beyond the statute and record of conviction in conducting a CIMT analysis.  This “third step” permitted adjudicators to examine any additional evidence deemed necessary to resolve the CIMT question.  The third step allowed for examination of evidence like police reports, witness statements, and other documents which may not have been subjected to a criminal court’s evidentiary standard for conviction, i.e. proof beyond a reasonable doubt.  The AG’s decision thus essentially dismissed nearly a century of judicial precedent, and permitted the use of dubious evidence against aliens in removal proceedings.

The Fifth Circuit’s ruling vacates the AG’s 2008 decision and reinstates the traditional categorical and modified categorical inquiries as the governing law for CIMT analyses in the Fifth Circuit.  However, at least two other federal circuit courts so far have afforded deference to the AG’s decision, leaving an unresolved circuit split ripe for resolution at the Supreme Court in perhaps the not-to-distant future.

Category: VERDIN Blogs, VERDIN News
Previous Post: « On April 2015 VERDIN hosted a free seminar on Investor and Business Visas
Next Post: Traveling During Removal Proceedings »

Sidebar

VERDIN LAW DALLAS

At VERDIN, our clients are always the highest priority. Built on a foundation of exceptional customer service, VERDIN is highly regarded for its responsiveness to clients.

We understand that our clients are entrusting their jobs, families, and futures to the firm, and we treat that trust with the utmost respect.

VERDIN Dallas Immigration Law
900 Jackson Street, Suite 535
Dallas, TX 75202

Main 214-741-1700
Toll Free (800) 656-4232

Contact Us

VERDIN
Dallas Immigration Law

At VERDIN, our clients are always the highest priority.

Built on a foundation of exceptional customer service, VERDIN is highly regarded for its responsiveness to clients. We understand that our clients are entrusting their jobs, families, and futures to the firm, and we treat that trust with the utmost respect.

VERDIN Immigration Law
900 Jackson Street, Ste 535
Dallas, Texas 75202

(214) 741-1700

(800) 656-4232

Isaul Verdin, VERDIN Law

Isaul VERDIN - Texas Board Certified - Immigration Law
VERDIN Law - American Immigration Lawyer's Association

VERDIN is a full service immigration law firm providing comprehensive immigration solutions to international employers, investors, startups, individuals and families.

Every VERDIN client receives a customized plan designed to deliver the very best results.

Today, VERDIN capitalizes on its experience, industry relationships, and cutting edge technology to guide clients safely and efficiently through the intricate U.S. immigration system.

Recognized by the Best Lawyers in America© 2021 - Isaul Verdin, Dallas Immigration Lawyer
Contact VERDIN Law

(214) 741-1700

Copyright © 2021 · Dallas Immigration Lawyer VERDIN LAW • Immigration Attorney · All Rights Reserved

VERDIN Law is a full service immigration law firm providing comprehensive immigration solutions in the Dallas Fort Worth area.

The information on the Verdin Law Firm website has been reviewed and approved by Isaul Verdin and is for general information purpose only.

Privacy Policy